Melanie gives the question due consideration, like it's a riddle Dr. Caldwell has posed to her. She knows that ice cream comes in a lot of different flavors, and it's easy to get overwhelmed by the thought of picking just one. Then again, she doesn't have to pick just one, either. They have more than one kind here, and they could go to the shops and get more if they wanted to.

So, after giving it a bit of thought, she declares, "Chocolate." She knows how popular that is. People sell it even in shops that aren't primarily for food. It comes in a lot of different forms, too, so while she might want to try others, chocolate and ice cream seems like a good combination to start with. It's efficient, in case this doesn't last as long as she'd like it to.

"And whatever goes best with that," she adds, though she's happy to defer to James' expertise on that front. He'd know better than she would.